Fipresci Home the international federation of film critics  
  about us | festival reports | awards | undercurrent   contact | site map 
home > festival reports > Toronto 2013  

coming soon

Toronto, 2013

Amazing Catfish
"The Amazing Catfish" (Claudia Sainte-Luce)
"Ida" (Pawel Pawlikowski)

With 20 more feature-length films than it offered last year — 289 by the festival's count — the 2013 Toronto Film Festival (TIFF) could have been described as bursting at the seams. It certainly felt like it. With such high-profile awards contenders as 12 Years a Slave, Gravity, and August, Osage County drawing a feverish international press community, and setting the table for the seasonal awards banquet-to-come, TIFF was operating with one fewer multiplex than it has used in previous years (albeit, somehow, with one more screen than it had last year) and the festival felt logistically chaotic, and physically uncomfortable.

Each selection featured fine films, though, from 72 countries, almost all of which were world, international or North American premieres. But the celebrity hubbub of TIFF, like it or not, eclipses the more modest films and subsumes any wider international impact. Frankly, it seemed that TIFF was poised at a crossroads: Stop pretending to be something cozy — stop boasting about your thousands of eager-beaver volunteers who can't, and shouldn't, be handed the responsibility of handling the day-to-day goings on at a world-class film event. Get professional. Or show fewer films.

What the festival showed did in fact include the kinds of film one actually goes to a festival to see — or used to, anyway. Films that one might never again get a chance to experience, that signify new talent blossoming, or about to, and the kind of immersion in cinema that involves an exchange of ideas about what the movies are, and are going to be.

You certainly saw that in a film like Gravity — not that there are any other films like Gravity, which has suddenly become the sine qua non of tech-oriented movies, one that marries actual ideas, profound ideas, with cutting-edge craft. For all its gifts, and grace, however, it is the electric, strobe-lit, 40-story version of the studio tent-pole picture, and as such predicts the future (or perhaps, destiny) of only a small number of films and filmmakers.

More inspiring from the under-$100-million-budget crowd was Mexico's The Amazing Catfish (Los insólitos peces gato), recipient of one FIPRESCI prize and a kind of lost-soul story: A young woman named Claudia (the magnetic Ximena Ayala), meets ailing matriarch Martha (Lisa Owen) in a hospital ward, and having little purpose or direction is adopted by Martha's family, fulfilling the duties and obligations the older woman's raft of children don't perform, either out of weariness or neglect.

Underlying director Claudia Sainte-Luce's often droll account of distressed domestic life is a knowing examination of how people look for a place to fit, a need to serve, and a family to belong to. Needless to say, The Amazing Catfish also redefines the family in very welcome ways. At the other end of the spectrum was the phenomenal Canopy, a wartime drama, an action-adventure saga and an experimental film: Can World War II be recreated, essentially through carefully choreographed cinematography and (most especially) sound, in the jungles of WWII Singapore? There, a lost Australian soldier, parachuting into hostile Japanese-controlled territory, allies with a similarly stranded Chinese soldier and struggles to survive. The effect of director Aaron Wilson's tour-de-force film — which manipulates the senses masterfully, and without much computerized enhancement — is visceral and anxious-making, despite having a cast of about a half dozen actors. (John Anderson)

Toronto (Canada, International Film Festival, September 5-15, 2013). Jury: John Anderson, USA, president ("New York Times", "Wall Street Journal"), Michael Ranze, Germany ("Film-dienst", "Ray"), Robenson Eksiel, Greece ("Ethnos"), Namrata Joshi, India ("Outlook"), André Roy, Canada ("24 Images"), Leslie James, Canada ("680 News Radio").

FIPRESCI Prize int the Discovery Program: The Amazing Catfish (Los insólitos peces gato) (Mexico, 2013, 89min, DCP) directed by Claudia Sainte-Luce. Print Soure: Pyramide International (5, rue du Chevalier de Saint George, Paris 75008, France), T +33 (1) 4296 0220, Fax +33 (1) 4020 0551,,

FIPRESCI prize for "Special Presentation": Ida (Poland, 2013, 80min, DCP) directed by Pawel Pawlikowski. Print Soure: Fandango Portobello Sales (12 Addison Ave, Holland Park, London,  W11 4QR, UK, Phn: +44 (20) 7605 1396, Fax +44 (20) 760 51391,,

At the Toronto International Film Festival, the FIPRESCI prize for "Special Presentation" was awarded to "Ida", directed by Pawel Pawlikowski. The jury noted: "The prize is awarded to Pawel Pawlikowski's Ida for a layered and humane exploration of issues of religious and personal identity. With its very original, austere yet poetic imagery it brings alive the gravity and grimness of history."

For the TIFF "Discovery Program", the FIPRESCI Award was given to The Amazing Catfish (Mexico) directed by Claudia Sainte-Luce. The jury remarked: "Claudia Sainte-Luce shows a precocious, playful and poignant grasp of the fluid nature of family and the capability of the human heart under the most dire conditions for generosity, empathy and tenderness, in her vibrant debut The Amazing Catfish."


Viewing and Reflecting: Seeing Ourselves and the World through TIFF 2013. This year, there were close to 300 feature-length films from 70 countries, and I was able to see just over 30 of them. The Discovery Program consisted of 28 films, 16 of which were world premieres, meriting closer attention and special consideration. Leslie James' report. arrow.
Relationships On A Breakdown Mode. Namrata Joshi examined the competition section of TIFF. arrow.
Heavyweight People. Fat was a theme in several of the festival's Discovery films at the Toronto International Film Festival. Yes, fat: The shall-we-say generously proportioned were having a moment in the autumnal sun, where the subject of heavyweight people was sort of blowing up in a medium that ordinarily promotes the idea that eating is sinning, and that any worthwhile woman can be outweighed by her handbag. John Anderson's report. arrow.
Gloomy Episode of Poland's History. André Roy reviewed Polish Pawel Pawliskowski's FIPRESCI prize winner Ida. arrow.
Act of Violence. Anger, social alienation, guilt and punishment in the "Special Presentations" section by Michael Ranze. arrow.
Toronto Discovered. You may have no trouble finding your way around in the squared-off city, yet as an avid professional filmgoer you might have a tough time trying to put things into perspective, given the vast program of more than 280 titles in various sections. Robbie Eksiel's impressions. arrow.



recent festivals


Toronto 2013

bullet. Index
bullet. Viewing and Reflecting
bullet. Relationships On A Breakdown Mode
bullet. Heavyweight People
bullet. Gloomy Episode
bullet. Act of Violence
bullet. Toronto Discovered

Language editor:
Leslie James